인삼 조사포닌을 기존의 고온 MeOH 추출/n-BuOH 분획법 및 고온 MeOH 추출/Diaion HP-20 흡착/MeOH 용출법과 새로이 시도된 고온 MeOH 추출/cation AG 50W흡착/$H_2O$ 용출/n-BuOH 추출법(AG 50W법), 상온 MeOH 추출/Diaion HP-20 흡착/MeOH 용출법(상온추출법)과 EtOAc/n-BuOH 직접 추출법으로 분리한 다음 기존의 HPLC/RI 방법으로 ginsenoside조성을 비교한 결과 EtOAc/n-BuOH 직접 추출법을 제외하고는 큰 차이가 없었으나 분리능과 감도가 우수한 HPLC/ELSD방법을 사용한 결과, ginsenoside $Rb_2$, Rf, $Rg_1$ 및 $Rh_1$ 등을 뚜렷이 식별할 수 있었고 추출 및 분획방법에 따라 조사포닌간 ginsenoside의 현저한 조성차이를 볼 수 있었다. 특히 AG 50W법에 의해 분리된 조사포닌에서 뚜렷한 prosapogenin 피크를 볼 수 있었으며 LC/MS의 결과, ginsenoside $Rb_1$, $Rb_2$ 등의 7종의 주종 사포닌 이외에도 5종의 prosapogenin과 1종의 chikusetsusaponin을 포함한 총 13종의 ginsenoside를 동정하였다. 새로이 정립한 HPLC 분석조건, 즉 $NH_2$ 대신에 $C_{18}$ column을 사용하고 $KH_2PO_4/CH_3CN$ gradient로 상온추출법으로 분리한 조사포닌을 분석한 결과, malonyl ginsenoside 피크를 용이하게 확인할 수 있었다.
This study was carried out to investigate the difference of ginsenoside compositions in crude ginseng saponins prepared by five different methods including three new methods. Two known methods are hot methanol(MeOH) extraction/n-butanol(n-BuOH) fractionation and hot MeOH extraction/Diaion HP-20 adsorption/MeOH elution. Three new methods are hot MeOH extraction/cation AG 50W $absorption/H_2O$ elution/n-BuOH extraction, cool MeOH extraction/Diaion HP-20 adsorption/MeOH elution and direct extraction with ethyl acetate(EtOAc)/n-BuOH. Analysis of ginsenoside composition in the crude saponins by conventional HPLC/RI(Refractive Index) did not show great difference between methods except EtOAc/n-BuOH method. However, HPLC/ELSD (evaporative light scattering detector) employing gradient mobile phase afforded fine resolution of ginsenoside Rf, $Rg_1$ and $Rh_1$, and great difference of ginsenoside compositions between methods. LC/MS revealed that large amount of prosapogenins were produced during the pass through the cation exchange (AG 50W) column being strongly acidic. Six major ginsenosides such as $Rb_1,w;Rb_2,$ Rc, Rd, Re and $Rg_1$, 5 prosapogenins and one chikusetsusaponin were identified by LC/MS. A newly established HPLC method employing ODS column and gradient mobile phase of $KH_2PO_4/CH_3CN$ revealed that malonyl ginsenosides were detected only in the crude saponin obtained from cool MeOH extraction.
