Metalaxyl 살균제 저항성(RPC)과 감수성(SPC) 고추역병균주(Phytaphthora capsici)들에 대한 2-N-benzyl-5-phenoxy-3-isothiazolone 유도체들의 살균활성을 비교분자 유사성 지수분석(CoMSIA)과 홀로그램 구조-활성 관계(HQSAR) 방법으로 분석하였다. 두 균주의 살균활성에 대한 PLS 계산결과, 교차 확인값($q^2$)과 Pearson 상관계수($r^2$) (CoMSIA: RPC; $q^2=0.675,;r^2=0.942$, SPC; $q^2=0.350,;r^2=0.876$ 및 HQSAR: RPC; $q^2=0.519,;r^2=0.869$, SPC; $q^2=0.483,;r^2=0.990$)를 비교한 바, 두 방법 모두 양호한 분석 결과를 나타내었다. 그리고 CoMSIA 등고도로부터 특히, RPC에 대한 선택적인 살균활성 요소는 phenoxy-기의 meta, para(C1-C6) 위치에 소수성이 작고 입체적으로 크지 않은 H-결합 받게가 치환 될 경우이었으며 CoMSIA 보다는 HQSAR 방법이 높은 예측성을 나타내었다.
Two different QSAR methods, the comparative molecular similarity indices analyses (CoMSIA) and hologram quantitative structure activity relationship (HQSAR) are studied for the fungicidal activities ($pI_{50}$) of 2-N-benzyl-5-phenoxy-3-isothiazolone derivatives against sensitive (SPC: 95CC7105) and resisitive (RPC: 95CC7303) phytophthora blight fungus (Phytaphthora capsici). According to the findings from these QSAR investigation, the cross-validation value, $q^2$ and Pearson correlation coefficient, $r^2$ in the two methods were CoMSIA: RPC; $q^2=0.675,;r^2=0.942$, SPC; $q^2=0.350,;r^2=0.876$ and HQSAR: RPC; $q^2=0.519,;r^2=0.869$, SPC; $q^2=0.483,;r^2=0.990$, respectively. Therefore, the two models of comparative statistical significance were obtained. From the CoMSIA contour maps, the important factors for selective fungicidal activity against RPC are to be expected that the lower hydrophobic and not bulkiness substituent as hydrogen bonding acceptor have to introduce to meta and para-position (C1-C6) on the phenoxy moiety. And the results of prediction suggest that HQSAR method showed higher fungicidal activity than CoMSIA method.
